Ellis Hospital in Schenectady. Photo: Tyler A. McNeil / Wikimedia Commons, CC0
New York Attorney General Letitia James has ordered St. Peter’s Health Partners to stop keeping its Schenectady cardiologists from telling patients where they will practice next, as most of the group prepares to leave for Ellis Medicine in January.
In a cease-and-desist letter dated Nov. 20, First Deputy Attorney General Meghan Faux told St. Peter’s Health Partners Medical Associates, P.C. to “immediately cease and desist instructing its employees, including all Cardiology Associates of Schenectady employees, that they cannot share future practice plans with patients.” The company has 10 business days to confirm it has complied, or face “further action by this office,” the letter says.
The stakes are large for the Schenectady area. The letter says withholding the information “endangers continuity of patient care for tens of thousands of cardiac patients in the Schenectady area with serious health conditions.”
How the dispute got here
Cardiology Associates of Schenectady has cared for patients in the area for decades, including at Ellis Hospital on Nott Street. According to the attorney general’s announcement, St. Peter’s and Ellis ended their agreements to share medical services in June, after which St. Peter’s sought to move all cardiac procedures from Ellis to St. Peter’s.
Lawsuits followed. In August, Ellis sued St. Peter’s, accusing it of forcing the practice’s cardiologists to sign contracts with noncompete clauses that would bar them from working for a competitor like Ellis for a year. St. Peter’s countersued, alleging Ellis tried to recruit the doctors in violation of an earlier agreement. In September, St. Peter’s also sued two of the cardiologists, accusing them of urging colleagues to leave. The doctors’ current contracts end in December.
The attorney general’s office said it acted on allegations in the court record. The letter cites filings in a case St. Peter’s brought in state Supreme Court in Albany County, Index No. 911090-26.
What the state says the law requires
The letter argues that blocking doctors from talking to patients about their plans conflicts with state Health Department rules for outpatient care, which call for continuous care by the same provider, specifically 10 NYCRR 405.20. It also warns that misleading patients about where their doctors will be would violate the state’s consumer protection laws, Executive Law 63(12) and General Business Law sections 349 and 350.
The letter goes further on the contracts themselves. It says noncompete and non-solicitation clauses “implicate New York’s strong public interest in free competition,” citing decades of court rulings, and that St. Peter’s conduct “betrays” its stated charitable mission.
“Open communication between doctors and their patients is critical to New Yorkers’ health,” James said in a statement. “St. Peter’s is putting their patients at risk by attempting to hide crucial information about where their doctors will be practicing.”
Ellis Medicine President and CEO Paul Milton said in a statement shared with CBS6 that 22 cardiologists and 10 advanced practice providers have chosen to join Ellis, and that the hospital’s next priority is getting them timely access to the medical records of “the nearly 45,000 patients who rely on them.” The station said it had asked St. Peter’s for comment.
St. Peter’s Health Partners, part of Trinity Health, runs St. Peter’s Hospital in Albany among other sites. Ellis is Schenectady’s main hospital, in a city that this month also passed a 2027 budget with a 14% tax increase.
The next marker is St. Peter’s response to the attorney general, due within 10 business days of the Nov. 20 letter. The cardiologists who are leaving are expected to start at Ellis in January. More from the area is in our Local News section.
Add Observer Chronicle as a preferred source on Google (opens in a new tab)


